Speculative Roster Construction for 2027
A recent analysis published by Sports Illustrated proposes a significant restructuring of the Baltimore Orioles' infield as the team approaches the 2027 season. The article suggests that General Manager Mike Elias and owner David Rubenstein have failed to adequately address defensive needs, specifically criticizing their leadership and spending habits regarding the "alleged core" of the roster.
The proposed scenario centers on moving away from current shortstop Gunnar Henderson, who is identified in the report as a third baseman rather than a shortstop. The analysis notes that Henderson is scheduled to reach free agency in 2027 and is projected to earn $10.5 million in arbitration for the upcoming year.
Instead of retaining Henderson at shortstop, the Sports Illustrated piece suggests acquiring Milwaukee Brewers shortstop Joey Ortiz. In this hypothetical lineup, Ortiz would start 150 games at shortstop, with Blaze Alexander covering the remaining innings.
Proposed Defensive Alignment
The article outlines a specific defensive configuration for the 2027 season that involves demoting current second baseman Jackson Holliday. The author argues that Holliday is "overmatched" at second base and proposes trading him to provide a fresh start.
Under this reshaped infield, Jordan Westburg would play second base as much as his body allows, with Blaze Alexander covering the rest of the innings at shortstop. This creates a dual-role scenario for Alexander, who would split time between the middle infield positions depending on Westburg's availability.
First Base Rotation and Power Dynamics
The analysis extends beyond the middle infield to propose a significant shift in first base responsibilities. The author suggests that Pete Alonso would serve as the primary first baseman, playing 100 to 120 games during the season.
To fill the remaining time at first base, the article projects that Samuel Basallo and Coby Mayo would split the duties. This rotation aims to manage workload while providing offensive production from multiple sources within the infield structure.
Broader Implications for Baltimore
The speculation regarding Joey Ortiz highlights potential trade interest in the Milwaukee Brewers' shortstop, positioning him as a key piece in this hypothetical future. The article frames these moves as necessary corrections to past strategic decisions, particularly concerning the long-term placement of Gunnar Henderson.
By proposing the departure of Henderson and the trade of Holliday, the analysis suggests a complete re-evaluation of the team's defensive identity. The projected 2027 infield would feature Ortiz at shortstop, Westburg or Alexander at second base, Alonso, Basallo, or Mayo at first, and Henderson potentially shifted to third base if he remains with the organization, though the focus remains on his impending free agency.