Martha Marcy May Marlene

Brady Corbet

-

Sarah Paulson

Lucy

John Hawkes

Patrick

Hugh Dancy

Ted

Louisa Krause

Zoe

Tobias Segal

Cult Member

Michael Chmiel

Scruffy Man (uncredited)

Elizabeth Olsen

Martha

Christopher Abbott

Max

Julia Garner

Sarah

Tomas Deckaj

-

Maria Dizzia

Katie

Adam David Thompson

Bartender

Anne Marie Dentici

-

Zorinah Juan-Lieber

-

Allen McCullough

Man in Home #2

Sean Durkin

-

Rachel Bernstein

Interviewee (uncredited)

Beth Stephens

-

Lauren Molina

Cult Member

Louisa Braden Johnson

Cult Member

Gregg Burton

Man in Home #1

Barbara Aragon

-

Donald E. Benjamin

-

Stacie A. Blaut

-

Carole L. Brookman

-

Heather Boyd

-

Ellie Brooks

-

Richard S. Clark Jr.

-

Sal Crescitelli

-

Josephine E. DeSimone

-

Jarret Featherbay

-

Jill Halpern Steingart

-

Jonathan Huppke

-

Louis H. Jawitz

-

Fred A. Kahn

-

Heather M. Kayal

Party Guest

Jin Kyung Kim

-

Ava K. Levy-Lynn

-

Franco C. Lisacchi

-

Nancy I. Mahoney

-

Joanne McDonough

-

John F. McDonough

-

James P. Minoux

-

Annette Nazari

-

J. Clifford Noonan

-

Claire Payevsky

-

Dalton Powell

-

Jackson Powell

-

Peyton Powell

-

Samantha Powell

-

Christopher Roe

-

Aziza O. Simpkins

-

Judith M. Skordinski

-

Jessica K. Smith

-

Jot Stephens

-

Jennifer L. Vega

-

Rahmel Thomas Walker

-

Diana Masi

Cult Member (uncredited)

Ramona Adair

-

Michele Erdman

-

Zachary Stuart-Pontier

-