Storytelling

Mary Lynn Rajskub

Melinda

Aleksa Palladino

Catherine

Paul Giamatti

Toby Oxman

Robert Wisdom

Mr. Scott

Conan O'Brien

Himself

Nancy Anne Ridder

Joyce

John Goodman

Marty Livingston

Selma Blair

Vi

Xander Berkeley

Mr. DeMarco

Franka Potente

Toby's Editor

Leo Fitzpatrick

Marcus

Julie Hagerty

Fern Livingston

Steve Railsback

Mr. Kirk

Mark Webber

Scooby Livingston

Tina Holmes

Sue

Pat Kiernan

TV News Announcer (voice) (uncredited)

Jennifer Elise Cox

Musical Theatre Actress (uncredited)

Angela Goethals

Elli

Lupe Ontiveros

Consuelo

Timothy Bird

-

Todd Solondz

-

Alan Oxman

-

Jim Titus

Football Player (uncredited)

Maria Thayer

Ami

Jonathan Osser

Mikey Livingston

Noah Fleiss

Brady Livingston

Devorah Rose

Lucy

Steve Rosen

Ethan

Mike Schank

Mike the Cameraman

Jessica Dunphy

Cheryl

Nick Maltes

Esposito

Crista Moore

Elizabeth St. Clair

Andrew Marantz

Stanley

Frederick B. Owens

Football Coach

Barry Jordan

Dr. Barry Jordan

Robin Goodman

Dr. Robin Goodman

Eric Nieves

Dave

Marisa Redanty

Onlooker #1

Ilana Levine

Onlooker #2

Gina Priano

Student (uncredited)

Tom Schimmels

Man in Toby's Apartment (uncredited)

Leslie Garvin

-

Victoria Lang

-