Stalemate Over Fossil Fuel Language and Funding
Climate negotiations at the COP31 UN climate summit in Turkey reached a standstill on Saturday night as nations prepared for a potential confrontation with Saudi Arabia and its allies regarding the phase-out of fossil fuels. Co-conveners Australia and Turkey held meetings with scores of countries throughout Saturday until late evening, but the fortnight-long talks overran their scheduled timeline without reaching a resolution.
The primary obstacle to an agreement involves a coalition of approximately 130 countries insisting on including a reference to the "transition away from fossil fuels" in the final outcome document. This language was originally agreed upon at COP28 in Dubai in 2023, but Saudi Arabia and its allies prevented further progress on implementing it at that time. At last year’s COP30, Brazilian hosts pledged to draft a global roadmap for the phase-out.
During this year's summit, the resolution appeared in a first draft of the agreed outcome but was excised from a revised draft published on Thursday. Following further talks that produced no progress, late Saturday evening discussions were led by the European Union, the United Kingdom, the world’s least developed countries, and small island states.
Tuvalu climate minister Maina Talia described including a reference to fossil fuels as a "red line" for his country. He argued that without this inclusion, delegates are "wasting our time," according to reports from the Irish Times.
Disagreements on Technology and Finance
Beyond the core fossil fuel language, significant disagreements persist over "carbon capture and storage" (CCS) technology and a target to derive 35 percent of the world’s energy from electricity by 2035. Saudi Arabia is advocating for strong recommendations supporting CCS, while other countries object, arguing that such technology may perpetuate the fossil fuel industry.
Some delegates suggested a compromise might be possible if the role of CCS is downplayed and the push for electrification is strengthened. However, developing countries continue to demand bolstered rights to funding from rich nations for climate adaptation.
Mohamed Adow, director of the Power Shift Africa think tank, reported that rich countries spent two weeks finding reasons not to deliver promised financial support. He stated that the meeting appears to be unraveling due to these failures.
Campaigners have blamed the lack of progress on the fossil fuel industry, dependent countries, and the failure of rich nations to deliver finance. Nick Dearden, director of Global Justice Now, said fossil fuel interests are holding delegates to ransom. Harjeet Singh, global convener of the Fill the Fund campaign, stated that developing countries cannot transform their economies while drowning in disasters and debt. He asserted that the COP failed due to a lack of money and will from those who caused the crisis.
Logistical Chaos and Quorum Risks
The collapse of negotiations has created significant logistical challenges for attendees. The talks, originally scheduled to end Friday evening, looked likely to continue into Sunday morning, with many delegates rescheduling flights in response to the uncertainty.
This delay carries procedural risks for the conference's legitimacy. If enough delegates leave due to the extended timeline, the conference may no longer meet the quorum required under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, potentially invalidating any final agreements reached.

